Home›Lesson Plans›The Arts›Visual Arts · Grade 9

Art Critique

Ninth graders learn to critique art like professionals — using the four steps of describe, analyze, interpret, and judge — to discuss artwork thoughtfully, respectfully, and with real insight.

Grade 9Response50 minutes1 class periodArtistic ProcessExplicit teaching4 StandardsNCAS
Start the Lesson
Lesson at a Glance

Everything you need before the bell rings

Learning Objectives

Students will be able to…

  • ✓Explain art critique.
  • ✓Use the four steps.
  • ✓Give respectful feedback.
  • ✓Discuss art with insight.
Essential Question

“I like it” isn’t a critique. Real art critique follows a thoughtful process. What are the steps to critique art well?

0
Lesson Phases
0
Vocabulary Terms
0
Standards Aligned
0
Interactive Task
Explore · Interactive

The Art Critique Explorer

Project this and tap each step. Have students learn the four steps of art critique.

⚖️ Explore the art critique steps — tap eachTry it

The Lesson · Artistic Process (Look · Explore · Create · Share · Reflect)

50 minutes, five moves

Tap any phase to open the teacher moves and student actions.

1

Look — More Than “I Like It”

5 min

“I like it” isn’t a critique — real critique follows a process. What is it?

👩‍🏫 Teacher Moves

  • Show an artwork.
  • Ask for a real critique.
  • Get ready.

🎒 Student Actions

  • Look.
  • Consider.
  • Get ready.
2

Explore — Art Critique

12 min

Students explore.

👩‍🏫 Teacher Moves

  • Send students to the Art Critique Explorer.
  • Note describe before judge.
  • Note staying respectful.

🎒 Student Actions

  • Tap each.
  • Note them.
  • Name.
3

Create — Create

14 min

Students create.

👩‍🏫 Teacher Moves

  • Describe an artwork.
  • Analyze how it’s made.
  • Interpret its meaning.

🎒 Student Actions

  • Describe.
  • Analyze.
  • Interpret.
4

Share — Share

12 min

Students share.

👩‍🏫 Teacher Moves

  • Give a full critique.
  • Back up your judgment.
  • Be respectful.

🎒 Student Actions

  • Critique it.
  • Back it up.
  • Respect.
5

Reflect — Reflect

5 min

Students respond.

👩‍🏫 Teacher Moves

  • Name a critique step.
  • Explain describe vs. judge.
  • Complete the exit ticket.

🎒 Student Actions

  • Name one.
  • Explain it.
  • Complete the exit ticket.
Standards Alignment

Built to the standards you report on

Aligned to the National Core Arts Standards (Visual Arts, HS Proficient).

NCAS
VA:Re7.2.HSI

Analyze an artwork.

NCAS
VA:Re8.1.HSI

Interpret meaning in art.

NCAS
VA:Re9.1.HSI

Evaluate an artwork.

NCAS
VA:Re7.1.HSI

Perceive and respond to art.

Differentiation

One lesson, every learner

Multilingual Learners

ELL / EMERGING READERS
  • Critique-step cards.
  • Sentence frame: “I see ___; it means ___.”
  • Use an artwork.

Support & Access

IEP / 504
  • Start with describe and judge.
  • Use one artwork.
  • Do one step.

Stretch & Extend

GIFTED / EARLY FINISHERS
  • Critique a famous work.
  • Write a full critique.
  • Lead a group critique.
Materials

What to gather

  • 📽️Projector / board
  • 🖼️Artwork examples
  • 💻The Art Critique Explorer
  • 📝Critique frames
  • ✏️Pens
  • 🎫Exit-ticket slips
Vocabulary

Key terms — hover for a quick definition

critiquea thoughtful evaluationdescribesay what you seeanalyzestudy how it’s madeinterpretfind the meaningjudgeevaluate with reasonsrespectfulkind and thoughtfulelementsthe building blocks of artprincipleshow art is organized
Evaluate

Exit Ticket

Preview the three formative checks. Tap “Sample answer” to see what mastery looks like — hide them before you print for students.

QUESTION 1
What is the FIRST step of art critique?
Describe — say only what you see, with no opinions yet.
QUESTION 2
What do you do in the “interpret” step?
Ask what the artwork means — its message, mood, or story.
QUESTION 3
What makes a critique respectful?
It’s thoughtful and kind, focused on the work, not the person.

Reflect: critique with care.

Have students critique one artwork using all four steps: describe, analyze, interpret, judge. A printable critique sheet is in the Arts library.

Study · Flashcards

Study the key terms

Tap a card to flip it, then rate whether you knew it. Built from this lesson’s vocabulary.

🃏 Art CritiqueFlip
Card 1
Term
Tap to flip →
Meaning
0

Nice work!

Practice · Quiz

Check your understanding

A quick self-check with instant feedback, drawn from this lesson’s key terms.

📝 Art CritiqueQuiz
Score: 0
1 / 6
Question 1
0%

Nice work!

Practice · Worksheet

Printable worksheet

A print-and-go review sheet with a built-in answer key. Tap “Show answer key” to reveal answers, or print the clean version for students.

🖨️ Art CritiquePrint
Name: ________________________
Date: ____________

Part A · Write the word that matches each meaning

Word bank: analyze, critique, describe, elements, interpret, judge, principles, respectful
  1. the building blocks of art
  2. a thoughtful evaluation
  3. study how it’s made
  4. how art is organized
  5. evaluate with reasons
  6. find the meaning
  7. say what you see
  8. kind and thoughtful

Part B · Show what you learned

  1. What is the FIRST step of art critique?
  2. What do you do in the “interpret” step?
  3. What makes a critique respectful?
Answer key — Part A: 1) elements · 2) critique · 3) analyze · 4) principles · 5) judge · 6) interpret · 7) describe · 8) respectful
Part B: 1) Describe — say only what you see, with no opinions yet. 2) Ask what the artwork means — its message, mood, or story. 3) It’s thoughtful and kind, focused on the work, not the person.